The John Paul II Pastoral Centre (Pastoral Centre) exists to assist the Archbishop in the exercise of his ministry of governance. Pastoral Centre personnel, comprised of clergy and laity who are either employees or volunteers, carry out important responsibilities on behalf of the Archdiocese of Vancouver. At all times they must act in its best interests and in a manner consistent with their duties, which include, but are not limited to, carefully stewarding its resources. They are to exercise particular care in conducting their affairs, so as to avoid conflicts (or the appearance of conflicts) between their own interests (including the interests of their family members and other related parties) and the interests of the Archdiocese.
For the purposes of this Policy, a conflict of interest is a circumstance in which the personal interests of an individual, or group of individuals, may potentially or actually be opposed to (or be perceived to be opposed to) the interests of the Archdiocese.
The Policy applies to all Pastoral Centre personnel. For greater clarity this includes all clergy, laity, employees and volunteers serving any of the offices and entities delineated on the following John Paul II Pastoral Centre organizational chart: https://rcav.org/about/administration/organizational-chart
This Policy identifies key areas in which conflicts of interest most often arise and outlines certain actions which, due to the potential for conflict, are to be avoided. It delineates procedures for addressing potential and real conflicts of interests. The guidelines and examples provided are not intended to be definitive or all-inclusive and do not purport to cover every situation that could give rise to a conflict of interest.
A. Areas of Potential Conflict of Interest
Personal Gain
A conflict of interest may occur when Pastoral Centre personnel receive a personal benefit from a business relationship with the Archdiocese or from an outside business with which the Archdiocese has a relationship.
Pastoral Centre personnel may not be involved in any negotiation or transaction on behalf of the Archdiocese where the individual has a personal or financial interest in the outcome of the negotiation or transaction unrelated to their role with the Pastoral Centre.
Family Members and Personal Relationships
A conflict of interest may occur when Pastoral Centre personnel have the ability to enhance or promote the interest of a family member.
Pastoral Centre personnel may not:
- participate in a decision to hire, re-assign or promote a family member or a close friend;
- supervise a family member nor have direct or indirect authority over employment or contract-related decisions pertaining to a family member or a close friend.
For the purposes of this part of the Policy, “family member” is defined as a spouse, child, parent, sibling, niece or nephew, aunt or uncle, cousin, grandparent, grandchild or in-law.
Situations may arise where broader familial relationships, friendships, dating a co-worker, or other close personal associations can cause real or perceived conflicts of interest. Pastoral Centre personnel should be sensitive to these concerns and demonstrate good judgement in the best interest of the Archdiocese and in keeping with the spirit and intent of this Policy. Any uncertainty should be discussed with the individual’s direct supervisor, with the Director of Human Resources or with the Delegate for Operations.
Outside Employment and Other Non-RCAV Activities
Pastoral Centre personnel are free to engage in outside business activities on their own time. However, these activities must not conflict, or have the potential to conflict, with the best interests of the Archdiocese or with an individual’s ability to fulfill properly their role with the Archdiocese.
As a general guideline, Pastoral Centre personnel may not work for, or be engaged in business activities for, businesses that supply goods or services to the Archdiocese.
It is a conflict of interest to have an outside interest that demands so much time and energy that it interferes with one’s ability to complete their Pastoral Centre work. This includes any personal, community, and charitable activities that require time and effort during normal working hours, except for situations where the individual is acting as a representative of the Pastoral Centre and with the explicit written permission of their direct supervisor.
Any uncertainty should be discussed with the personnel member’s director supervisor, with the Director of Human Resources or with the Delegate for Operations.
Information
Pastoral Centre personnel may not disclose or use for any personal reason, including personal gain, any confidential information gained through their working relationship with the Archdiocese.
Gifts and Benefits
For the purpose of this Policy, a “gift” may be any tangible item of value such as cash, gift certificates, artwork, etc. A “benefit” includes intangible items such as discounts, services, special privileges, etc. that are not available to the general public. Gifts and benefits can also include things that benefit the recipient’s family and friends. While the value of gifts and benefits may be difficult to quantify monetarily, they are often highly valued by the intended recipient and therefore have the potential to create undue influence and distort objectivity in making decisions that are in the best interest of the Archdiocese. Because of this, accepting gifts from contractors, suppliers, service providers, community partners etc. can be highly problematic.
Under no circumstances may a gift or benefit be offered or received that serves to influence the judgement or conduct of a person in a position of power, authority, or trust to try and obtain an advantage.
Gifts of cash or cash equivalent should not be authorized, offered or accepted, regardless of the amount.
Independent of the problems associated with gifts and benefits, it is natural to accept and receive gratitude, and to demonstrate good will. Because of this, there are limited circumstances where small gifts and benefits may be acceptable.
Acceptable gifts and benefits, offered or accepted in the normal course of business, should be less than $50 CAD in value and might typically include:
- attendance at local sporting, cultural, or entertainment events
- business lunches or dinners
- hospitality at special events
- small tokens of appreciation
Such expressions of gratitude and good will must be unsolicited, infrequent with any particular business or person, in good taste, and undertaken for legitimate business reasons.
Pastoral Centre personnel may not authorize, offer or accept, directly or indirectly, gifts or benefits to or from any organization or person having business dealings with the Archdiocese other than those in accordance with this Policy.
Because of the importance of not confusing appropriate expressions of gratitude and good will with inappropriate attempts to gain advantage and influence, reflecting upon the following questions is helpful:
- Would the gift be considered normal and customary given the nature of your role with the Archdiocese?
- If the gift or benefit was made widely known, would it be viewed by others as reasonable and appropriate?
- Would you be completely comfortable disclosing the details of the gift or benefit to your colleagues and supervisor(s)?
When faced with the prospect of offering or accepting a gift or benefit, it is advisable for all Pastoral Centre personnel to discuss the issue with your supervisor, the Director of Human Resources or the Delegate for Operations.
Directors and managers with supplier selection, negotiation, purchasing or contract management roles within the Archdiocese are often subject to a higher level of scrutiny and accountability regarding gifts and benefits. They may be subject to more stringent purchasing requirements and/or may face additional challenges in maintaining appropriate relationships with suppliers, service providers and other entities. Directors and managers must, therefore, keep accurate records of all gifts and benefits received. When faced with the prospect of a gift or benefit of value greater than $50, that gift or benefit may not be offered or received without the explicit and written permission of the individual’s direct supervisor.
B. Procedures for Addressing Conflict of Interest
Duty to Disclose
A key element in successfully addressing potential conflicts of interest involves timely and accurate disclosure. This is the duty and responsibility of all Pastoral Centre personnel.
At times, Pastoral Centre personnel may be faced with a potential conflict of interest that does not appear to be related to their specific work. In such cases, the person(s) involved should disclose the existence and nature of the potential conflict of interest to their direct supervisor, the Director of Human Resources or the Delegate for Operations.
Disclosure shall be made promptly any time an actual, apparent, or potential conflict of interest arises and before the consummation of any contract, transaction or arrangement that is the subject of the conflict of interest.
Responding to Disclosures
Any supervisor receiving disclosure of conflict of interest from personnel will inform and raise the issue with the Director of Human Resources or the Delegate for Operations.
These three parties, hereafter referred to as the Conflict of Interest Committee (“COIC”), will meet to consider the issue diligently and systematically. Personnel with the potential or real conflict of interest may be asked to make a presentation, provide information, and answer questions at the meeting, but will leave the meeting during any subsequent discussion and/or voting on the transaction or arrangement in question.
If, following disclosure and initial consideration, the COIC determines that a conflict exists or that the perception of a conflict is material, a recommended remedy will be proposed and, if necessary, reviewed by legal counsel.
An accurate record of all disclosures of conflict of interest and the subsequent actions and decisions will be maintained by the COIC.
In some circumstances, a possible conflict of interest may not prohibit the Archdiocese’s agencies from allowing the transaction or activity. For example, the real or perceived conflict may not be material enough or be of sufficient practical importance to impede the employee’s proposed work, contract or relationship in question. In some situations, the COIC may deem it sufficient that personnel involved should not participate in any decision made about certain transactions.
In all circumstances, a careful examination of each potential conflict of interest and the application of appropriate procedures in accordance with policy are required.
C. Annual Statement of Compliance
Annually, employees in a senior role in the Archdiocese and any of its agencies will complete and sign a statement which affirms that they:
- have received a copy of the Conflict of Interest Policy,
- have read and understood the Policy, and
- are in compliance with the Policy.
The statement will also elaborate on any instances where a conflict of interest was evident and will clearly outline the procedures followed and action taken to resolve the conflict.
Annual statements of compliance will be distributed and returned to the Director of Human Resources who will review all submissions and prepare an annual summative report to the Archbishop. The annual statements and summative report will be maintained for a minimum of seven years by the Director of Human Resources.
Violations of the Policy
If the appropriate supervisor finds that a member of Pastoral Centre personnel has failed to fulfill their obligations under the Conflict of Interest Policy, the supervisor will inform the member of this finding and will give the individual an opportunity to respond.
After hearing the response of the individual and making further investigations as necessary, the supervisor, and, if necessary, the Delegate for Operations or the Archbishop, will conclude whether the individual has failed to fulfill their obligations under this Policy.
In cases of a breach of this Policy, the appropriate disciplinary and/or corrective action will be taken.
Approved:
Memorial of Saint Oscar Romero
March 24, 2023
+ J. Michael Miller, CSB
Archbishop of Vancouver
The following policy is hereby superseded: Employment of Relatives (JPII), issued on December 12, 2016.
